Bit.ly, a new URL shortener, launches, but I’m not going to use it. Yet.

switchAbit, purveyors of wonderful web tools, have launched a new URL shortener called bit.ly. Besides a cute name, bit.ly has some nice developer-centric features that make it stand out among the hordes of these services (TinyURL, is.gd, twurl.nl, etc.). From Dave Winer’s post on the launch:

They asked what it would take for me to use bit.ly, I said: data. I need to know how many clicks each pointer got and where the clicks came from.

They gave me that, and thumbnails, permanent caching of the pages I’m pointing to (goodbye linkrot) and a lot of smart stuff going on behind the scenes that we’re not ready to talk about yet. (Though we told Marshall and he explained.) Here’s the info page for this post.

And, most important, an XML/JSON interface, so I can process all that data with my own programs.

As URL shorteners go, it looks great. I love the caching using Amazon S3/EC2 cloud resources, the stats, the developer features (XML and JSON), and again, the name is cute.

But I won’t be switching my bits (ha!) to use bit.ly. At least, not yet. Why? Because it’s still way too big of a pain in the butt to use these services, without some tools to make it easier.

Even with a bookmarklet (which you can click to shorten the URL of the page you’re on), it costs me way too much to time load the page for the URL I want to shorten, click the bookmarklet, wait for the shortener page to load (and, optionally, tell it “yes, I really want to shorten this”), and then get my shortened URL, which I then have to manually copy for pasting elsewhere.

Right now, I use TinyURL as my URL shortener (mostly for posting links in Twitter, where every character counts). Not because it has better features than any other shortener (in fact, compared to bit.ly, TinyURL comes up lacking in a lot of ways), But I keep using it for one reason: the TinyURL Creator Firefox addon.

TinyURLMenu.jpg

With that addon installed, all I have to do to shorten a URL is right click on any page (OR any URL on the page), choose “Create TinyURL”, wait a second (during which my TinyURL is created and automatically placed on the clipboard for pasting), then click the “Close” button and paste the shortened URL wherever it’s going.

TinyUrl Creator.jpg

Simple and fast, it saves me at least 10 seconds every time I shorten a URL (which I do many times per day, thanks to Twitter).

I WANT to start using bit.ly. But I won’t until there’s a FireFox addon for it. I can’t code worth beans, or I’d do it myself, and I know the developers are busy, having just launched a few hours ago. But having a Firefox extension makes shortening URLs MUCH faster and simpler, and as soon as I can get one for bit.ly, I’ll dump TinyURL like a bad high school romance, and “switch my bits”. (ha! See that? I did it again!) ;-)


8 Responses to “Bit.ly, a new URL shortener, launches, but I’m not going to use it. Yet.”


  1. 1 Chris Messina

    Fortunately Fluid.app offers this functionality natively. Not like that matters necessarily, but thought I’d point out that at least @iTod is thinking about this. ;)

  2. 2 Josh Bancroft

    Chris, that’s a very good point. Fluid.app is very, very cool, and I had completely forgotten that it can shorten URLs natively. Thanks! :-)

  3. 3 Chris Messina
  4. 4 Mike

    http://turo.us has been doing all of that for months… :)

    You just need to sign up as it got over-run by people “abusing” the service.

  5. 5 Josh Bancroft

    Mike, does turo.us have a Firefox addon?

  6. 6 Mike

    @josh there’s a bookmarklet so I guess, “yes”… :)

  7. 7 Josh Bancroft

    @mike Ah, but a bookmarklet isn’t the same as an extension. I can’t right click and say “shorten this link”. I have to GO to the link I want to shorten, THEN click the bookmarklet, THEN wait for the service to shorten it, THEN copy it to the clipboard.

    TinyURL Creator does all this for me in one click, saves a TON of time and effort. That’s why I love it.

  8. 8 videokeblog

    There’s a fairly new one, that uses Twitter username as part of the short URL.

    Check out http://knol.me

Leave a Reply



  • December 31, 1969 at 4:33 pm lee machen
    i'd like to use the TinyURL plugin for firefox3 but the official one doesn't support it. are you using an older version?
  • December 31, 1969 at 4:33 pm Josh Bancroft
    I'm using FF3, and it's just been working. But it's possible I forced it to work during the betas using Nightly Tester Tools to disable compatibility checking. I've been known to do that for extensions I really want to use. :-) At any rate, it's been working perfectly the whole time I've been using FF3 (since, like Beta 2), so I say go for it!